Pillows MyPillow Premium Pillow Review: Is This Popular Pillow Worth the Hype?

Finding the perfect pillow can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. I’ve tried everything from memory foam to down alternatives, and I know how frustrating it is to wake up with a stiff neck or restless sleep. That’s why I decided to give the MyPillow Premium Pillow a try—it’s been making waves for its customizable comfort and unique design.

If you’re anything like me, you want a pillow that’s supportive yet soft, something that keeps its shape without feeling like a brick. With so many glowing reviews, I was curious to see if this pillow lived up to the hype. In this review, I’ll share my experience, what stood out, and whether it’s worth adding to your bedtime routine.

Overview Of MyPillow Premium Pillow

The MyPillow Premium Pillow stands out for its patented interlocking fill, designed to provide adjustable comfort and support. Unlike traditional pillows that lose shape or flatten over time, this pillow maintains its structure, catering to a range of sleep positions. I found its customizable nature appealing, as users can shape the fill to support their neck and head alignment.

It’s available in different loft levels, allowing individuals to choose based on their body size and preferred sleeping position. For example, side sleepers may prefer a firmer fill, while stomach sleepers often opt for a softer option. The breathable cotton cover enhances comfort by promoting airflow, which helps regulate temperature throughout the night.

This pillow is also machine-washable and dryer-safe, making maintenance simple. My experience with the washing process revealed that the fill retained its integrity after several cycles, ensuring durability. The MyPillow Premium is marketed as a US-made product, which adds to its appeal for those who value domestically produced goods.

One unique feature is its availability in multiple sizes, including Standard/Queen and King, catering to various bed types. Its versatility makes it a practical addition to many bedding setups, whether as a primary pillow or a layering option. These features collectively set the MyPillow Premium apart in a competitive pillow market.

Features Of MyPillow Premium Pillow

As someone who spends hours testing and reviewing bedding products, I thoroughly enjoy exploring the features that make a pillow stand out. The MyPillow Premium Pillow offers some distinct elements that aim to enhance comfort and practicality.

Material And Construction

The MyPillow Premium Pillow features a thin, soft, and breathable 100% cotton cover. The double-stitched seams provide durability, ensuring the cover remains intact even after extended use. Inside, the patented three-piece interlocking shredded poly foam fill sets this pillow apart. The foam chunks come in three varied sizes, designed to interlock and mold to the sleeper’s needs, offering customized support and contouring. This unique construction combines adaptability with long-lasting resilience.

Design And Customization Options

The pillow’s 2-inch gusseted sidewall adds another layer of functionality by making fill manipulation easier and helping the pillow maintain its shape without sagging. Size options include standard/queen, measuring 16.5 x 26 inches, and king, at 16.5 x 32 inches. While slightly smaller than industry averages, these sizes still offer versatility for most users. Maintaining hygiene is simple, as the pillow is both machine washable and dryable. This helps prevent dust mites and bacterial buildup, which is essential for anyone prioritizing cleanliness in their sleep environment.

Support And Comfort Levels

The fill’s interlocking design allows the pillow to adjust to various sleeping positions, whether back, side, or stomach. This versatility ensures optimal neck and head support, promoting proper spinal alignment. The shredded foam pieces provide a balance of softness and firmness, offering cushioning without compromising support. From my testing, the breathability of the cotton cover coupled with the airflow within the foam enhances temperature regulation, making the pillow a comfortable choice for individuals who experience night sweats or temperature sensitivity.

Pros And Cons Of MyPillow Premium Pillow

As someone passionate about testing bedding products, I’ve explored many pillows over the years. The MyPillow Premium Pillow brings a mix of features that cater to diverse sleep needs while also leaving room for improvement.

Benefits

• Machine Washable and Dryable: Cleaning this pillow is simple. It holds up well in the washer and dryer, keeping it hygienic by removing bacteria and dust mites over time.
• Breathable Design: The 100% cotton cover enhances airflow, making it suitable for hot sleepers who want a cool surface.
• Customizable Firmness Levels: The four fill levels (Yellow, White, Green, and Blue) let users choose the firmness that works best for their sleep position, whether side, back, or stomach sleeper.
• Back Sleeper Support: Its ability to offer support for back sleepers stands out, even if some foam compression occurs with regular use.
• Adjustable Fill: The shredded foam interior is easy to manipulate, allowing users to fold or shape the pillow for personalized comfort.
• Made in the USA: Knowing products are manufactured domestically is an added plus for those seeking American-made quality.

Drawbacks

• Foam Compression Over Time: While supportive initially, the foam tends to compress after extended use, potentially reducing its effectiveness.
• Lack of a Luxurious Feel: The shredded foam and lightweight cotton cover may lack the premium feel that some high-end pillows offer.
• Firmness Levels Aren’t Perfectly Tailored: Despite having multiple options, the specific fill levels might not meet everyone’s exact preference.
• Higher Price Point: Given the mixed performance over the long term, the cost might feel steep compared to other pillows with similar features.

Performance And Durability

The MyPillow Premium Pillow is marketed as an option for those seeking adjustable support and comfort. After testing it extensively, I noticed its construction reveals strengths and some clear weaknesses tied to durability.

Long-Term Comfort And Shape Retention

This pillow features shredded poly foam filling, initially offering decent support for back and side sleepers. The 2-inch gusset design and 100% cotton cover enhance its structure, making it seem promising at first use. Over time, though, the foam rapidly compresses, leading to flattened sections that affect comfort and spinal alignment. Frequent re-fluffing is required to regain its shape, which might not satisfy users looking for consistent long-term support.

Compared to materials like memory foam or latex, the poly foam used in this pillow struggles to maintain shape, reducing its usefulness for long-term comfort. It’s suitable for short-term needs but feels less reliable over months of regular use.

Cleaning And Maintenance

One of this pillow’s strongest features is its washable and dryable design. I washed it several times during my use, and the cotton cover showed excellent durability, with seams holding up well. Proper cleaning ensures hygiene, especially for allergy-sensitive users, and sets it apart from some non-washable alternatives.

However, repeated washing can exacerbate the foam’s tendency to clump and lose its structure, which adds to the need for re-fluffing. While the convenience of machine-washable poly foam stands out, it comes at the cost of faster wear compared to foam within less flexible designs.

Comparison With Other Pillow Brands

When comparing the MyPillow Premium Pillow with other popular brands, a few key differences stand out. For instance, its interlocking polyurethane foam filling caters to customizable support, unlike Casper Pillow’s layered design with coated polyester fibers. This construction helps the MyPillow adapt to various sleep positions but can result in uneven firmness after prolonged use, requiring frequent fluffing.

The cover materials also set these brands apart. MyPillow uses a 100% cotton cover, while Casper opts for Supima cotton with a percale weave. Casper’s material feels more luxurious and has greater durability, making it appealing for users who prioritize premium textures.

Machine washability is a shared feature across both brands. The MyPillow retains its shape best with delicate care, though its foam filling may clump over time. Casper’s coated fiber fill, on the other hand, holds up better to repeated laundering without losing its structure.

In terms of firmness options, MyPillow Premium provides four levels: Yellow, White, Green, and Blue. This variety suits users looking for personalized comfort levels. Casper operates on a universal firmness approach, appealing to those who prefer a consistent, medium feel across all pillows.

While the MyPillow Premium includes sizes like Standard and King, competing products such as Casper typically only offer Standard/Queen and King. Having distinct firmness levels and size options makes MyPillow Premium more versatile in accommodating individual preferences. However, Casper’s evenly distributed polyester fibers maintain better support retention over time, which some may find more dependable than MyPillow’s adjustable interlocking foam.

For warranties, MyPillow offers a 10-year warranty and a 60-day money-back guarantee. Casper typically provides similar terms depending on the retailer, ensuring both brands are backed by a consumer-friendly policy.

As someone deeply invested in bedding product quality, I notice MyPillow Premium is better for users needing adjustable features. However, brands like Casper balance comfort and durability for consistency seekers.

Should You Buy The MyPillow Premium Pillow?

I’ve spent years testing bedding products, and the MyPillow Premium Pillow offers several benefits for the right user. Its machine-washable design simplifies cleaning, making it a hygienic option for those concerned about allergens like dust mites. The breathable construction, thanks to shredded foam chunks, ensures better airflow, which helps reduce overheating during the night.

With four firmness levels—Yellow, White, Green, and Blue—you can select a version tailored to individual needs. This adjustability gives it an edge for back sleepers, who often struggle to find a balance between softness and spinal support. However, the foam can compress over time, requiring regular re-fluffing to maintain its loft and shape.

On the downside, the shredded poly foam filling tends to feel lumpy and uneven. Some sleepers may find this texture uncomfortable compared to smoother alternatives like solid memory foam. Another limitation is its non-adjustable fill. Unlike pillows that allow users to add or remove stuffing, MyPillow requires selecting one of its preset firmness levels during purchase.

The MyPillow Premium might appeal to those prioritizing ease of care and breathability. However, if you’re seeking consistent long-term support or dislike lumpy textures, this pillow may not meet your expectations.

Conclusion

The MyPillow Premium Pillow has its strengths, especially for those who value breathability, machine-washable convenience, and customizable firmness options. Its design caters well to back sleepers and offers decent initial support. However, the shredded foam fill and compression over time might not work for everyone, particularly if you’re after consistent long-term comfort.

While it’s a solid choice for some, it may not meet the needs of those who prefer a smoother texture or more luxurious feel. If adjustability and ease of care are priorities, it’s worth considering, but keep its potential drawbacks in mind before making a decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the MyPillow Premium Pillow made of?

The MyPillow Premium Pillow is made from a patented interlocking shredded poly foam fill and features a 100% cotton cover with double-stitched seams. This design allows users to manipulate the fill for customized comfort and support.

Is the MyPillow Premium Pillow suitable for all sleeping positions?

Yes, the MyPillow Premium Pillow is designed to support various sleeping positions. Its customizable filling and different loft levels cater to back, side, and stomach sleepers.

Can the MyPillow Premium Pillow be washed?

Yes, the MyPillow Premium Pillow is machine washable and dryable, making it easy to maintain hygiene and prolong the pillow’s lifespan.

Does the MyPillow Premium Pillow help with temperature regulation?

Yes, the MyPillow Premium Pillow has a breathable cotton cover that promotes airflow, helping to regulate temperature and reduce overheating during sleep.

How does MyPillow compare to Casper pillows?

MyPillow offers customizable interlocking foam with four firmness levels, while Casper pillows provide a luxurious feel with durable polyester fiber layers. Casper is better for consistent comfort, whereas MyPillow is ideal for adjustable support.

Does MyPillow Premium Pillow lose its shape over time?

The MyPillow Premium Pillow may compress and flatten with use, especially in the long term. Regular re-fluffing is required to maintain its shape and support.

How many firmness options does the MyPillow Premium Pillow offer?

The MyPillow Premium Pillow is available in four firmness levels: Yellow, White, Green, and Blue, catering to different preferences.

Is the MyPillow Premium Pillow worth the price?

The MyPillow Premium Pillow is worth considering for its customizable features, machine-washable design, and temperature regulation. However, its higher price and potential for foam compression might not appeal to everyone.

What sizes does the MyPillow Premium Pillow come in?

The MyPillow Premium Pillow is available in two sizes: standard/queen and king, making it versatile for various bedding setups.

What are the main drawbacks of the MyPillow Premium Pillow?

The pillow’s main drawbacks include foam compression over time, a potentially lumpy texture, and firmness that may not suit all users. It also has a higher price point compared to similar options.