Casper Select Mattress Review: Is This the Perfect Balance of Comfort and Support?

Shopping for a mattress can feel overwhelming with so many options out there, but finding the right one is worth the effort. If you’re anything like me, you want something that balances comfort, support, and value without endless trial and error. That’s where the Casper Select mattress caught my attention.

This mattress promises a mix of plush comfort and firm support, designed to suit a variety of sleepers. With its reputation for quality and affordability, I couldn’t help but wonder—does it really live up to the hype? Let’s dive into what makes the Casper Select stand out and see if it’s the perfect fit for a great night’s sleep.

Overview Of Casper Select Mattress

The Casper Select mattress combines thoughtful design and reliable performance. It’s a 12-inch foam mattress crafted with four distinct layers, each targeting specific aspects of comfort and support. Its medium-firm feel caters to a broad range of sleeping preferences, making it versatile for different sleep positions.

The top layer uses breathable foam to enhance airflow and prevent overheating. Beneath it, a responsive layer adds bounce and mobility, which helps with ease of movement. The third layer offers zoned support, firmer near the hips and softer around the shoulders, promoting proper spinal alignment. Finally, the durable base layer provides stability and prevents sagging over time.

This mattress works well on most solid foundations, including slatted bases and platform beds. Its soft-knit cover feels luxurious to the touch and adds an extra layer of comfort while enhancing the mattress’s durability. Designed to reduce motion transfer, it’s ideal for couples or restless sleepers. Additionally, the CertiPUR-US certification ensures its materials meet strict safety and environmental standards.

Key Features Of Casper Select Mattress

As someone who’s passionate about testing and reviewing mattresses, I’ve spent time analyzing the Casper Select mattress. It combines thoughtful design with quality materials to address different sleep needs.

Construction And Materials

The Casper Select mattress is crafted with an all-foam design and a solid 12-inch profile. The first layer is soft yet breathable open-cell poly foam, engineered to promote airflow and dissipate heat effectively. Beneath that lies a high-density memory foam layer, offering excellent contouring and relieving pressure around key points like the shoulders and hips.

One standout feature is the zoned transition layer. Casper’s proprietary Zoned Support creates a firmer zone in the center to support the lower back, while softer sections allow easier sinkage for the shoulders. Lastly, the durable base layer, made from high-density support foam, prevents sagging and helps keep the body well-aligned. All of this is wrapped in a hand-sewn, removable cover that makes cleaning hassle-free.

Comfort And Firmness

With a firmness rating of 6.5 on a 1-10 scale, I found Casper Select slightly firmer than a true medium-firm mattress. This feel supports various sleep styles, particularly back sleepers needing lumbar alignment or stomach sleepers looking for consistent support. The foam layers balance plushness and support, delivering a comfortable yet structured sleeping surface.

Motion Isolation And Support

I put the Casper Select to the test for motion isolation, which it handles impressively. The memory foam layer absorbs movement efficiently, so partners sharing the bed won’t be disturbed by tossing and turning. The zoned support and firm base foam contribute to reliable edge-to-edge support, making the mattress a good candidate for couples seeking stability and reduced motion transfer.

Temperature Regulation

Many all-foam mattresses tend to trap heat, but the Casper Select mitigates this common issue. The top layer’s open-cell poly foam improves airflow, dispersing heat better than traditional foams. This makes it suitable for sleepers who get too warm during the night, helping to maintain a cooler sleeping environment.

Pros And Cons Of Casper Select Mattress

The Casper Select mattress offers a mix of benefits and drawbacks based on its design, features, and performance. Here’s my breakdown after testing it extensively.

Pros

• Firmness and Versatility: With a firmness rating of 7 out of 10, the Casper Select provides a bit more support than the traditional medium-firm mattresses. This firmness level suits back sleepers and those seeking extra support for spinal alignment.
• Zoned Support: The proprietary Zoned Support layer delivers targeted support to the lower back while maintaining comfort for the shoulders. This feature promotes better posture and minimizes pressure points across sleeping positions.
• Edge Support: Excellent edge support makes it perfect for couples or single sleepers who shift toward the mattress’s edges. There’s no sagging or rolling effect when lying or sitting near the edges.
• Motion Isolation: The all-foam design reduces motion transfer efficiently. It’s a great choice for couples or anyone sensitive to their partner’s movements during the night.
• Temperature Regulation: The open-celled poly foam layer enhances airflow, preventing heat build-up on the surface. While not the coolest mattress I’ve tested, it keeps a neutral temperature for most sleepers.
• Certifications and Build Quality: Its CertiPUR-US certification ensures safe materials, while the durable 12-inch structure prevents sagging over time, even with regular use.

Cons

• Limited Cooling: Although it includes breathable foam, it’s not ideal for extreme hot sleepers. If overheating is a concern, this might fall short compared to mattresses with advanced cooling technologies.
• Firmness Preference: The 7 out of 10 firmness level may feel too firm for strict side sleepers or those who prefer a softer sleeping experience.
• All-Foam Construction: The foam layers support well but lack the responsiveness of hybrid models. This limits bounce, which some users may prefer for better ease of movement.
• No Trial Period: Depending on where it’s purchased, the Casper Select may not include a trial period. This limits risk-free testing for those unsure about the fit.

This mattress ticks many boxes for comfort, durability, and practical features, but it may not satisfy everyone’s preferences.

Who Should Consider The Casper Select Mattress?

As someone who tests and reviews countless mattresses, I can say the Casper Select is well-suited for specific types of sleepers based on its medium-firm construction, zoned support, and thoughtful design.

• Back Sleepers: Back sleepers often need a balance of support and pressure relief to maintain proper spinal alignment. The Casper Select excels in this area with its Zoned Support layer, offering firmer lumbar support while providing softer areas for the shoulders. Its medium-firm feel (6.5 on the firmness scale) makes it an excellent choice for this group.
• Combination Sleepers: Sleepers who change positions during the night may appreciate the Casper Select’s versatility. Its responsive foam layers provide mobility, making it easier to switch from one position to another without feeling stuck.
• Couples: Motion isolation is another highlight of this mattress. The all-foam design absorbs movement effectively, reducing sleep disruptions for partners who toss and turn. The zoned support also ensures that each person experiences tailored comfort regardless of body type or sleeping style.
• Budget-Conscious Shoppers: With Costco’s pricing, the Casper Select offers premium features like zoned support and durable foam layers at a budget-friendly cost. It’s ideal for those seeking a high-quality mattress without breaking the bank.

Individuals who sleep exclusively on their stomach or need extra pressure relief for side sleeping may find better options elsewhere due to the firmness level and limited deep contouring.

Comparison With Other Casper Mattresses

As someone who tests every mattress I come across, I’ve had the opportunity to compare the Casper Select with other Casper models, particularly the Casper Original. While both mattresses offer great quality, they cater to slightly different preferences.

• Firmness and Feel: The Casper Select offers a firmer sleeping surface, rated at 7/10 on the firmness scale, compared to the Casper Original, which sits around 6.5-7/10. This slight difference makes the Casper Select better suited for back and stomach sleepers, while the Casper Original might feel more adaptive for combination sleepers.
• Construction: Both mattresses share a multi-layer all-foam design, but the Casper Select includes an additional layer of memory foam under the top layer. This extra layer enhances pressure relief and gives a subtly firmer feel compared to the Casper Original. They both feature Casper’s Zoned Support system, which I find invaluable for targeted lower back support and optimal spinal alignment.

With the Casper Select being 12 inches thick, it’s slightly taller than the Casper Original, which comes in at 11 inches. This difference adds a bit more durability and plushness to the overall feel of the mattress. If height and structural density matter to you, the Select takes the lead.

• Price and Availability: One notable distinction is that the Casper Select is exclusive to Costco. This limits accessibility unless you’re a member, but it does offer excellent value for the features provided. The Casper Original, on the other hand, is available directly through Casper and other retailers, usually with additional perks like trial periods and promotions.

For sleepers seeking zoned support and a slightly firmer profile, the Casper Select stands out. However, those who prioritize a trial period or need a mattress that’s a tad softer may lean toward the Casper Original. Both excel in motion isolation and overall support, but minor details set them apart depending on individual preferences.

Customer Reviews And Ratings

As someone who’s tested countless mattresses, the feedback from customers about the Casper Select aligns closely with my hands-on experience. It’s always insightful to see how others perceive a product that I’ve thoroughly reviewed.

Common Praise

Many customers appreciate the Casper Select for its balance of comfort and support, something I also noticed while testing. The medium-firm feel, rated at 6.5 to 7 on the firmness scale, provides a sweet spot that works well for back sleepers and lighter individuals. Its zoned support system stands out by offering firmer support under the lower back, which encourages proper spinal alignment—a feature I found very effective during my trials.

Another impressive highlight is its edge support. Unlike many all-foam mattresses that tend to sink near the edges, the Casper Select remains supportive and stable, making it easier to use the entire sleep surface. I’ve seen this praised extensively, and I couldn’t agree more. Additionally, many customers commend its affordability, as it delivers premium features at a significantly lower price than average mattresses—something I often point out to shoppers looking for high value.

Common Criticisms

Despite its many strengths, some users find the Casper Select too soft, especially heavier sleepers who require robust support. During my evaluation, I noticed that while it caters well to mid-weight and lighter individuals, those over 250 lbs might feel it lacks the firmness they need, particularly for the lower back.

These critiques mirror my observations, especially when comparing its suitability across different body types. While it’s an excellent all-rounder for most, it doesn’t entirely meet the demands of every sleeper.

Conclusion

The Casper Select mattress strikes a great balance between comfort, support, and affordability, making it a solid choice for a wide range of sleepers. Its thoughtful design, with zoned support and cooling features, caters to those who value proper spinal alignment and a cooler sleep experience.

While it may not be perfect for everyone, especially strict side sleepers or those who sleep extra hot, it offers impressive value for its price. If you’re looking for a dependable mattress with premium features and don’t mind the Costco exclusivity, the Casper Select is definitely worth considering.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes the Casper Select mattress unique?

The Casper Select mattress is unique due to its four-layer foam construction, zoned support system for spinal alignment, and medium-firm feel that suits a variety of sleep styles. It’s designed for comfort, support, and motion isolation, making it an ideal choice for couples and back sleepers.

Is the Casper Select suitable for hot sleepers?

Yes, the Casper Select features a breathable open-cell top layer that promotes airflow and helps regulate temperature. However, extreme hot sleepers may find its cooling properties limited compared to mattresses specifically designed for advanced cooling.

Who should buy the Casper Select mattress?

The Casper Select is ideal for back sleepers, combination sleepers, couples, and budget-conscious shoppers who want premium features like zoned support and motion isolation at a reasonable price. Side sleepers or strict stomach sleepers may prefer a softer or firmer option.

Does the Casper Select work for heavier people?

While the Casper Select offers good durability and support, some heavier sleepers may find it too soft and lacking in firmness. Those over 230 lbs may consider a hybrid or firmer mattress for more robust support.

Can the Casper Select help with back pain?

Yes, its zoned support layer provides firmer reinforcement for the lower back and softer sections for the shoulders, promoting proper spinal alignment, which can help alleviate back pain for many sleepers.

What is the firmness level of the Casper Select mattress?

The Casper Select has a firmness rating of 6.5–7/10, making it slightly firmer than true medium-firm mattresses. This firmness works well for back and stomach sleepers but may be too firm for strict side sleepers.

How does the Casper Select compare to the Casper Original?

The Casper Select is firmer, has an extra layer of memory foam for pressure relief, and is slightly taller at 12 inches. However, it’s exclusive to Costco, whereas the Original is widely available and includes a trial period.

Is there a trial period for the Casper Select mattress?

No, the Casper Select does not include a trial period since it is primarily sold through Costco. However, Costco’s return policy might allow for some flexibility in case the mattress doesn’t meet expectations.

Does the Casper Select mattress isolate motion well?

Yes, the all-foam design and memory foam layers of the Casper Select excel at absorbing movement, making it a great choice for couples or restless sleepers who want minimal sleep disturbances.

What foundations work best with the Casper Select mattress?

The Casper Select is compatible with most solid foundations, including platform beds, slatted bases with narrow gaps, and adjustable bases. Avoid using box springs, as they may not provide adequate support.